Tuesday, 14 December 2010

Libel Qualified Privilege

Libel

A false and malicious publication printed for the purpose of defaming a living person.

If you make a defamourty statement you;

-Lower someone in the estimation of right thinking members of the public.

-Causes someone to be shunned or avoided

-Disparages someone in their business, trade, office or profession

-Exposes someone the hatred, ridicule or contempt.

Defences;

Justification - Its true....you have evidence or you can prove it

Fair or honest comment - if it is an honest opinion based on facts or privilege matter, and comment must be of public interest.

Absolute Privilege

Qualified privilege (read further down)

Reynolds Defence - you are allowed to publish when the matter is in the public interest. It must also meet the ten points on Nicholls' list. (read below)



Definition as defined by the British Columbia Court of Appeal;

"The essence of the defence (of qualified privilege) is a duty, legal, social or moral, to publish the matter complained of to persons with a corresponding duty or interest to receive it."

Qualified Privilege is one of the defences against libel
. It allows a reporter to publish defamatory statements under certain circumstances. There are two types of qualified privilege.

Common Law Qualified Privilege
It is ok to make a defamatory comments provided it is in public interest. This does not mean that it is simply interesting. The allegation made when reporting must be fair, accurate and without malice.

Statutory Qualified Privilege

Journalists can attract this QP in many places such as public meetings, council meetings etc but the main two places would be court and parliament. As long as the journalist reports fast accurate and fair in order to avoid malice then they are in no danger of any libel action. The report must also be balanced. So here you must give the accused a chance to deny the allegations made towards them. This must be included in the same report, i.e "he denies the charges" and "the case continues". If you don't do this you will lose you qualified privilege and be at serious risk of libel.


ALBERT REYNOLDS vs SUNDAY TIMES

Following the resignation of Irish Prime minister Albert Reynolds, the Sunday Times published an article saying that Reynolds had lied to the Irish Parliament in order to cover a child abuse scandal. Although when challenged by Reynolds there was no evidence and they could not prove anything. However when the case came back into light in 1989 the court felt that "the Sunday Times" had a duty to publish what they knew as it was in the public interest.
So journalist now can now attract the Reynold defence so long as it passes the 10 point test made by Lord Nichols which are;

1. The seriousness of the allegation – the more serious the allegation, the more protection will be applied. If not at all serious then no protection can be enjoyed.

2. The nature of the information - is it a matter of public concern or in the public interest?


3 . The source of the information. If it is an authoritative source you may publish the statement made even if it turns out to be untrue.

4. The steps taken to verify the information.

5. The status of the information. Would need to ensure that this was not a repeat allegation.


6. The urgency of the matter.

7. Whether comment was sought from the claimant

8. Whether the article contained the gist of the claimant’s side of the story

9. The tone of the article.

10. The circumstances of the publication


And that is more or less it really that I can think of. The most important point to remember and must stress is that any report made where you wish to attract Qualified Privilege must be FAST ACCURATE AND FAIR to avoid and MALICE


Tuesday, 7 December 2010

Defamation: Not what the Doctor Ordered




Your reputation is very important to yourself and those around you. I would say it is even more important in your career. To damage your reputation in the mind of right thinking people will lead to all kind of problems. In every profession your reputation is everything, none more so than if your a doctor!

One of the most famous cases in which a doctor was defamed was that of Dr. Rahamim. He was described by channel 4/ITN as a 'Bogus Doctor'. They made the following allegations;

1. First that Mr. Rahamim was probably responsible for the death or serious injury of many of his patients including two who had died during their operations.

2. Secondly that Mr Rahamim was not competent to practice as a consultant thoracic surgeon and that he was seriously under qualified and inadequately trained.

3. Thirdly that he had fraudulently obtained his post as a Consultant by misrepresenting his qualifications and employment history.

4. Fourthly that Mr. Rahamim had dishonestly sent out letters to local GP’s in which he had falsely described himself as an FRCS.

5. Fifthly that he had dishonestly concealed from his employers the fact that as a result of injuries sustained in a road accident he was unable to operate safely.

6. Lastly that by reason of these matters the GMC ought to have Mr. Rahamim struck off.

These were serious allegations which led to multiple investigations into the work of Dr. Rahamim.

After finding no real evidence of any of the above being true, Dr. Rahmim sued in excess of £175,000.

The full statement in open court can be read here.

Whilst on the topics of Doctors and suing I have come across a couple more examples. It would seem its not always the press that we sue as I found out in this next case. in 1991 GP Dr. Smith was awarded £50,000 after a slanderous allegation made by fellow college Dr. Houston saying that Dr.Smith had groped both her and other female colleges.

So it would seem we have to be careful what we say in this world. Turns out a defame a day wont keep the doctor away!


Saturday, 29 May 2010

PART 1 - -


The election night,

So i get back to my house and put on my shirt, ready to be a TV star, or a round up guy, which ever you prefer. I made sure my hair was tidy and smart (not possible) and that my shoes were nicely polished.

So how did it all start? Well with a can of red bull to be frank. Then I was straight onto the computer gathering information, scanning for any extra information that I could add in. Frantically typing away as quick as my little fingers would allow, I altered my script preparing for the live round up. Then as the clock struck 9.55 pm I hit print...but disaster! No paper! none anywhere! so I ended up using my original script with scribbles and pen markings all over the place for the first live round up. So off I went into the MMC to go on camera. The most nerve racking part was not going on camera, but having only the length of the intro VY (8 seconds) to swap over the radio microphones. scary stuff, especially as I dropped mine on the first hand over. In a way sort of like a relay race in the fact you have to hand over the baton! sweaty hands, slippery radio mics, it was mad! After that it was back to the news room to type up my next script for the 11 o clock round up.


Not many people were in the news room. There was more milk than anything else which I must say was getting increasingly warm. This was a big concern of mine as I don't really like tea and coffee, I'm more of a milk man. However I couldn't let this distract me now, I was doing well on my second script and it was approaching the 11 o 'clock round up.

Aswas walked back into the MMC, the scent of hard work was more evident in the air. The smell of the sweat oozing out of everyone's body dominated the oxygen. I didn't want to hang around and so I didn't, I decided to suss out the gallery and see what was going on. Now I thought the MMC was bad, but when that gallery door opened I probably lost a couple of stone with the heat wave that hit me. Better than any sauna I've ever been in. Nevertheless the gallery all seemed to be in control. Everything was calm and everyone was working well as a team. So I left back to the news room where I was greeted by Tom giving a very energetic and enthusiastic live news update.






Wednesday, 26 May 2010

Socialism Hayek, Fred!

I was unaware that Hayek had such strong views on socialsm. He claimed that socialism was "impossible in a technical sense" and that it was a "solution that was not a solution" . I am still wrapping my brains and trying to dig deeper by what he really means. I have watched the video bellow quite a few times analysing what he is saying and the points he raises.





An example of existentialism? Not really sure what the video is trying to say here? Bit confused, is it just to show that we only know what is going on that second ? The guys asks if anything is wrong yet he is covered in blood ? Do we just take other peoples word for what they say ? I find this video odd and yet intriguing and interesting. Is this somewhat of what life might be like if we all lived in the existentialist universe ?

Thursday, 22 April 2010

track me






Tuesday, 20 April 2010

New Journalism - - Observe...


New Journalism was a style of writing that came about in the 1960's and 1970's. It tend to throw the conventional rules of being fast accurate a fair.... because this was simply boring and boring hides the truth. The main two leaders of this writing style were that of Tom Wolfe and Hunter S Thompson...who were both on drugs!




One of the techniques in which Wolfe used was that of observation, where he would simply observe and show what he was seeing though his eyes.

Does this still happen today ? Of crouse it does especially in documentaries but not so much in news. If you look at journalists such as Louis Theroux, in all his documentaries he appears on camera a lot, everything we see is what Louis sees and therefore being Louis opinion. Says it how it is.

I too like to adopt this New journalism writing style except I do not really write. I like to people watch, observe peoples lives. I like to call this people watching. Is that really new journalism ? Probably not and probably unrelated but hey ho, it filled another couple of lines!